Australian Rules Football (AFL) is more than just a sport; it’s a passion that has captured the hearts of millions. From the roar of the crowd in the MCG to the electric atmosphere at suburban grounds, AFL is an essential part of Australia’s sporting culture. Over the years, countless players have etched their names into the annals of history with their skills, determination, and memorable performances. But the question remains: who is the best AFL player of all time?
In this post, we’ll dive into the debate, examining the achievements, iconic moments, and legacies of the players who are often considered the greatest to ever play the game. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or someone new to the AFL, this post will provide insight into the legends who have shaped the sport as we know it today.
The Criteria: What Makes the Best AFL Player?
Before we dive into individual players, it’s important to understand the factors that define greatness in AFL. Being “the best” isn’t about a single outstanding season or an unforgettable moment. It’s a combination of skills, longevity, impact on the game, and overall contribution to the sport. Here’s what we consider when answering the question, who is the best AFL player of all time:
- Consistency: The best players remain at the top for long periods, showing brilliance season after season.
- Impact: Great players influence games in ways that go beyond statistics.
- Leadership: Many of the best players are also leaders who inspire their teams and fans alike.
- Achievements: Premierships, Brownlow Medals, All-Australian selections, and other individual honors are key indicators of greatness.
Let’s take a look at some of the key names that frequently appear in conversations about who is the best AFL player of all time.
Leigh Matthews: The Ultimate Competitor
When discussing the greatest AFL players, the name Leigh Matthews often comes up. Matthews, who played for the Hawthorn Hawks from 1969 to 1985, is considered one of the most complete footballers in history. His physicality, combined with his skill, made him a force to be reckoned with on the field.
- Achievements:
- Four-time AFL premiership player.
- Eight-time leading goal kicker for his club.
- Seven-time All-Australian selection.
Matthews was a brilliant forward, midfielder, and eventual coach, and he played a key role in shaping the AFL as we know it today. His ability to turn games with his skill, hard work, and fierce competitiveness makes him a prime candidate when asking who is the best AFL player of all time.
Gary Ablett Snr.: The Magic of the Sunset
Gary Ablett Snr., known for his spellbinding skills, is one of the most beloved players in AFL history. Playing for the Geelong Cats from 1982 to 1996, Ablett’s ability to take a game by the scruff of the neck was legendary. His agility, ball-handling, and penchant for producing miraculous moments made him an unforgettable figure in the sport.
- Achievements:
- Two-time Brownlow Medal winner.
- 10-time All-Australian selection.
- Known for kicking one of the most iconic goals in AFL history during the 1989 Grand Final.
Ablett’s brilliance in front of the goals, his natural flair, and his ability to dominate big games set him apart from others. For many AFL fans, his performances are often referenced when discussing who is the best AFL player of all time.
Dustin Martin: The Modern-Day Superstar
Dustin Martin is the embodiment of modern AFL excellence. Since his debut in 2010, Martin has cemented his status as one of the best players of his generation. Known for his explosive power, elite foot skills, and ability to shine on the big stage, Martin has already built a career that many compare to the best in AFL history.
- Achievements:
- Three-time Norm Smith Medalist (best on ground in the AFL Grand Final).
- AFL premiership player in 2017, 2019, and 2020.
- Brownlow Medal winner.
Martin’s incredible performances during the Richmond Tigers’ premiership runs and his consistent excellence have made him one of the most influential players of his era. While his career is still ongoing, his accomplishments have already placed him in the conversation of who is the best AFL player of all time.
Wayne Carey: The King of Full Forward
Wayne Carey, widely regarded as one of the most dominant full forwards in AFL history, played for the North Melbourne Kangaroos and is often called “The King.” Known for his ability to take control of a game, Carey could dominate in both attack and defense, making him a player feared by opponents and revered by fans.
- Achievements:
- Two-time AFL premiership player.
- Seven-time All-Australian selection.
- 1999 AFL Player of the Year.
Carey’s ability to be a match-winner and his leadership on the field helped North Melbourne secure multiple premierships during the 1990s. His influence over the game, particularly in the forward line, secures his place as one of the best in history, often making him a key figure in discussions about who is the best AFL player of all time.
Adam Goodes: The Heart of AFL
AFL’s rich history of diversity and inclusiveness shines through in the legacy of Adam Goodes. Playing for the Sydney Swans from 1999 to 2015, Goodes’ impact transcended beyond football. His ability to break barriers, lead with integrity, and perform at the highest level for over a decade makes him a standout.
- Achievements:
- Two-time Brownlow Medal winner.
- Two-time AFL premiership player.
- 5-time All-Australian selection.
Goodes was not only one of the most accomplished players in the AFL but also a trailblazer for Indigenous athletes in the sport. His resilience, talent, and leadership make him a pivotal figure in AFL history, leaving many to wonder, who is the best AFL player of all time. For many, Goodes’ achievements both on and off the field make him a top contender.
The Legacy of the Greatest: What Makes the Best Player?
While the players mentioned above are often considered the best in AFL history, it’s important to note that the title of “best” can vary depending on the criteria used. For some, the best AFL player of all time might be defined by the number of premierships won, while for others, it could be about individual skill, consistency, or impact on the community.
What’s clear is that the great players of AFL leave behind legacies that inspire generations to come. Their influence goes beyond the games they play; it’s about how they elevate the sport, push the boundaries of what’s possible, and serve as role models to fans and future players.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is generally considered the best AFL player of all time?
The title of the best AFL player of all time is subjective, with several legends frequently mentioned in discussions. Names like Leigh Matthews, Gary Ablett Snr., Dustin Martin, Wayne Carey, and Adam Goodes are often at the top of the list due to their outstanding careers and influence on the game.
What makes a player the best in AFL history?
A combination of skills, consistency, leadership, impact on the game, and individual achievements like premierships and Brownlow Medals contribute to a player’s greatness.
Is it about individual awards or team success?
Both individual awards and team success play a role in determining greatness. While individual honors like the Brownlow Medal highlight personal excellence, team achievements such as premierships often elevate a player’s legacy.
Has anyone won both a Brownlow Medal and multiple premierships?
Yes, players like Gary Ablett Snr., Adam Goodes, and Dustin Martin have won both the Brownlow Medal and multiple AFL premierships, cementing their place among the game’s best.
How important is leadership in determining the best AFL player?
Leadership is a key factor when determining the best player, as many of the greatest AFL stars are also captains or influential figures within their teams. Their ability to inspire and lead by example is essential in their overall legacy.
Why is Gary Ablett Snr. often called the best AFL player?
Gary Ablett Snr. is often regarded as the best due to his extraordinary skill, breathtaking goals, and memorable performances. His ability to dominate the field and create magic moments made him a fan favorite and a contender for the title of the best AFL player of all time.
What role do individual highlights play in a player’s legacy?
Individual highlights, such as iconic goals, incredible marks, and unforgettable performances in finals, help shape a player’s legacy. These moments often live on in the memories of fans and contribute significantly to the debate on who is the best AFL player of all time.
Will we ever have a definitive answer on who is the best AFL player of all time?
It’s unlikely that there will ever be a definitive answer, as the debate is shaped by personal preferences, the era in which fans grew up, and the criteria they prioritize. What remains certain is that the AFL has produced a multitude of great players, each contributing uniquely to the history of the game.
Conclusion
So, who is the best AFL player of all time? The answer is subjective, depending on who you ask and what they value most in a player. Whether you admire the skills of Gary Ablett Snr., the competitive fire of Leigh Matthews, or the modern brilliance of Dustin Martin, the AFL’s history is rich with legendary figures.
Each of these players has left an indelible mark on the game, and their stories will continue to inspire future generations of AFL stars. As fans, we may never truly agree on a single “best” player, but the beauty of AFL lies in its ability to produce a range of players who each define greatness in their own unique way.
